Memory Dysfunction in Learning Disorder, Psychopathology, and Social Behavior

Frank Wood
Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center
Winston-Salem, North Carolina


 Prerequisites: None

Course Description:  
Part 1.  Organic memory disorder is the most common false positive diagnosis in neuropsychology, behavioral neurology, and neuropsychiatry.  Accordingly, we review details of clinical memory testing—using verbal and visual tests of structured (narrative or geometric) and rote (list) memory.  In the context of relevant literature including methodological issues, we use the large (N=10,000+) Wake Forest School of Medicine adult and child longitudinal data base to illustrate the severity of the problem: many instances of memory failure—in brain injured as well as in “normal” patients—are secondary to chronic learning disorders or psychopathology. We will adduce “markers,” both within the tests themselves and in the larger context of the patient’s history, that give promise of distinguishing among various etiologies for memory dysfunction.  The goal is to define better methods of child and adult clinical assessment.

Part 2.   Given the empirical findings above, we then switch to theoretical considerations, both cognitive and neuroanatomical.  The episodic-semantic memory distinction will be reviewed for its heuristic value, and compared to other distinctions.  On the one hand, the episodic-semantic distinction appears at present to fit well, whereas the procedural-declarative distinction appears less useful or valid.  Similarly, certain functionally distinct (but overlapping) neuroanatomical systems may also map better to the episodic-semantic distinction,  for example in its resonance to the context-bound (episodic) properties of hippocampal, parahippocampal, and frontal cortical activity, or in its capacity to accommodate the distinct varieties of attentional processes (focal vs. diffuse, distal vs. proximal, etc.) that accompany all types of memory.  On the other hand, our goal is a better theory of memory.     

Part 3.   We then systematically review the types of memory disorder and functional neuroanatomical variation that characterize learning disabilities and psychopathology.   Dyslexia, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, autism, unipolar and bipolar affective disorder, and the schizophrenia spectrum will be among the specific conditions addressed.  Our perspective is equally clinical (how self-reported and clinician-tested memory deficits can help confirm or disconfirm a diagnosis) and theoretical (what the memory dysfunctions in these syndromes teach us about their underlying functional neuroanatomy).

Part 4.  Memory is a social as well as personal phenomenon.  Given the above studies, we should let their larger view of memory inform our understanding of larger social issues.  We thus will conclude the course by noticing the instances in anthropology, art, literature, law, politics, and history where memory or its failure (equally) can be seen as a central ingredient in human experience, motivating an astonishing range and power of social behaviors.
  

Reading List

The instructor recommends the following journal articles, which might well be consulted prior to the course.  Alternatively, copies will be available on site during the course.


        Wood F, Taylor B, Penny R, Stump D.  Regional cerebral blood flow response to recognition memory versus semantic classification tasks.  Brain Lang 1980; 9:113-122.

        Wood F.  Focal and diffuse memory activation assessed by localized indicators of CNS metabolism:  the semantic-episodic memory distinction.  Hum Neurobiol 1987; 6:141-151.

Wood FB; Brown IS; Felton RH.  Long-term follow-up of a childhood amnesic syndrome. Brain Cogn 1989 May; 10(1):76-86. 

Wood FB, Flowers DL.  Hyperfrontal versus hypo-Sylvian blood flow in schizophrenia.  Schizophrenia Bulletin 1990;16(3):413-424.

Felton RH, Wood FB.  Cognitive deficits in reading disability and attention deficit disorder.  J Learn Disabil 1989;22:3-13.

       Meyer MS, Wood FB, Hart LA, Felton RH.  Selective predictive value of rapid automatized naming within poor readers.  Journal of Learning Disabilities 1998;21(2):106-117.

      Garrett AS, Flowers DL, Absher JR, Fahey FH, Gage HD, Keyes JW, Porrino LJ & Wood FB.  Cortical activity related to accuracy of letter recognition.  NeuroImage, 2000;11:111-123.



The following books and chapters are optional background material which students may find interesting and relevant. Some of them could be consulted, if feasible, prior to the course, although copies of the relevant passages will also be available on site during the course.


     William James, Principles of Psychology, in two volumes.   Still the best and most up-do-date psychological treatment in the English language.   The account of attention is the best ever. 

     Charles Sherrington, The Integrative Activity of the Nervous System.  The origin of connectionism, with all the complexities and subtleties missing from later treatments. 

     George Talland, Deranged Memory.   Oft forgotten, but still the classical treatment of the details and complexities of the Korsakoff Syndrome, and the theoretical challenges. 

     Alexander Luria, either Higher Cortical Functions in Man, or Neuropsychology of Memory, both in English translation.   Unparalled descriptions of clinical memory deficit phenomenology.

      Karl Pribram, either Languages of the Brain or Brain and Perception:Holonomy and Structure in Figural Processing.  Holography, sort of—one way to escape oversimplified connectionist models.  

Walter Freeman, Societies of Brains.  Chaos math—another escape from simplistic connectionism.  
   
Benoit Mandlebrot, The Fractal Geometry of Nature.  Another alternative mathematical approach.    

      Kinsbourne M, Wood F.  Theoretical considerations regarding the episodic-semantic memory distinction.  In:  Cermak LS, ed.  Human memory and amnesia.  Hillsdale, New Jersey:  Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1982:195-217.

      Wood F, Ebert V, Kinsbourne M.  The episodic-semantic memory distinction in memory and amnesia:  clinical and experimental observations.  In:  Cermak LS, ed. Human memory and amnesia.  Hillsdale, New Jersey:  Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1981:167-193.

      Wood FB & Flowers DL.  Dyslexia: conceptual issues and psychiatric comorbidity.  In Rumsey J & Ernst M (eds.), Functional neuroimaging in child psychiatry.  Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, United Kingdom 2000:266-277. 

     Wood FB, Flowers Dl, Grigorenko, E.  The functional neuroanatomy of fluency or why walking is just as important to reading as talking is.  In Wolf M, (ed.), Dyslexia, Fluency, and the Brain.  York Press: Baltimore, Maryland, 2001: 235-244.